Must-Try Signature Cocktails Throughout The Caribbean

By Leah Freeman-Haskin


When it comes to drinking in the Caribbean, rum is always the liquor of choice. But how each island concocts their signature cocktail flavors with local ingredients to highlight the main attraction (rum), is very much part of the history and culture of the island.

Puerto Rico

Like many of the Caribbean islands, Puerto Rico, home to the Bacardi rum factory, is known for its rum. Some estimates state that nearly 80 percent of the rum consumed in the United States comes from Puerto Rico.

Signature Cocktail: Piña Colada

Ingredients: Light rum, coconut milk, pineapple juice, ice, and a cherry for garnish

RELATED: Most Beautiful Airbnb’s In The Caribbean With Beachfront Views


Many delicious cocktails are enjoyed throughout this vibrant island, and if beer is your preference, be sure to try Red Stripe Beer which has been brewed in Jamaica since 1938. But when it comes to cocktails, one famed rum mixture is a Jamaican classic.

Signature Cocktail: Old Jamaican

Ingredients: Mint, lime juice, rum, pure can simple syrup, Angostura, and a splash of champagne

St. Kitts

St. Kitts may be best known globally for its production of sugar cane, but one trip to this stunning Caribbean island and you may find that another local favorite is just as renowned.  

Signature Cocktail: A Ting with a Sting

Ingredients: Rum and Ting (a local grapefruit flavored soda)

St. Martin

On this small island in the Caribbean, the local drink is derived from guavaberries. These are small orange and black berries that grow on trees on the island, not to be confused with guavas. The locals combine them with rum to create a guavaberry liqueur.

Signature Cocktail: Guavaberry Kir

Ingredients: Guavaberry liqueur and champagne


This island’s most famous crop is the black pineapple, which isn’t actually black, but green when it’s at its most ripe stage. It’s no wonder that pineapple juice would make an appearance in this island’s signature cocktail.

Signature Cocktail: Antigua Smile

Ingredients: Rum, crème de banana, fresh pineapple juice and black pineapple garnish


Although not located in the Caribbean, Bermuda has a signature cocktail that has taken on global significance (and it also contains rum). The dark ‘n’ Stormy is the unofficial drink of Bermuda and of the global boating and sailing community. According to cnn.com, Bermuda, where the Dark ‘n’ Stormy was invented, is known as the shipwreck capital of the world, with 300 identified vessels lying ruined at the bottom of the surrounding North Atlantic Ocean.

Signature Cocktail: Dark ‘n’ Stormy

Ingredients: Rum, ginger beer, and lime

RELATED: How To Choose Your Next Caribbean Getaway


Barbados can boast having one of the oldest rum distilleries in the world: Mount Gay Rum, which has been in operation since 1703. It’s not surprising that rum makes a prominent appearance in this island’s signature cocktail.

Signature Cocktail: Rum Punch

Ingredients: Lime juice, simple syrup, rum and Angostura bitters

Travel Noire

Leah Freeman-Haskin

Want more?

Get exclusive, unpublished tips from Travel Noire's CEO to help you get off the beaten path, into the hearts of locals and onto a better, more cultured life.

Seven Must-Try Foods When Traveling To Antigua

Seven Must-Try Foods When Traveling To Antigua

Antigua is a foodie’s paradise, offering Caribbean staples like jerk chicken and roti, fresh seafood, and local delicacies for tourists to try. Wash it all down with a Wadadli beer or a fruity rum to complete your experience.  If traveling to the Caribbean islands are in your plans and you’re thinking about stopping by Antigua […]

Danielle Dorsey

The Best Beaches In Antigua

The Best Beaches In Antigua

The Caribbean island of Antigua is known as the “Land of 365 beaches,” giving you the option of visiting a different shoreline every day of the year. While hitting every beach on the island might be a little ambitious, here are the ones you absolutely can’t miss: Hawksbill Bay All beaches in Antigua are public, […]

Danielle Dorsey

A Foodie’s Guide To Antigua: What To Eat And Drink When On The Caribbean Island

A Foodie’s Guide To Antigua: What To Eat And Drink When On The Caribbean Island

The Caribbean island of Antigua was built on the concept of food. In fact, Antigua was first settled as a haven for rum distilleries and sugar plantations. Today’s Antigua is a foodie destination because of its fresh seafood, top-notch rum, and flavorful dishes. Although Caribbean islands have similar dishes, they all differ and have their […]

Kelsey Marie / Antigua